THE battle lines are being drawn over the creation of new provinces, as the two main partners in the ruling coalition experience a democratic reawakening. Both have recently taken to extolling the virtues of democracy — but each with their own spin.
On one side, PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari is taking a hard stand against a division of the provinces “imposed by force”. He has warned it might lead to bloodshed. As an alternative, he is pushing the idea of a political reset, which would entail recognising and respecting the mandate given to opposition parties, especially the PTI.
On the other side, various government ministers, mostly from the PML-N, are lecturing anyone who will listen on the merits of a public referendum. Though the controversies that followed the general elections are yet to be resolved, they are arguing, rather earnestly, that holding a nationwide referendum on new provinces is the fairest way forward.
Mr Bhutto-Zardari made an astute observation in his Tuesday speech at the Karachi Press Club: “In our history, a referendum has always been carried out for an undemocratic act and never a democratic one.” More jarring was his revelation that “up until today, neither the prime minister nor a single member of the cabinet has brought up the issue [of new provinces] with the president of Pakistan or me”.
What is one to make of this, considering that several members of the federal cabinet, including the ministers of interior, defence and information, have been making rather forceful public statements on the topic? It suggests the issue is being litigated in the media rather than discussed among the political leadership.
Mr Bhutto-Zardari seemed frustrated with the prime minister’s silence when his ministers seem eager to discuss it. It is also strange that the president, too, has not weighed in.
Perhaps the elders in both parties, the president among them, are testing the waters by letting Mr Bhutto-Zardari and second-tier ministers lead the conversation for now.
But the issue will be taken up in some form sooner rather than later, and they cannot wait until the eleventh hour to make their official positions known.
The administrative reconfiguration of an entire country — one that ranks among the most populous in the world — is no ordinary task. It is not merely a question of drawing lines on a map: nearly every branch of the state will need to be restructured around the new configuration, and this cannot be achieved through fiat.
The Constitution already sets out the route: altering a province’s limits requires a constitutional amendment backed by two-thirds of that province’s assembly.
Rather than trading referendums for ultimatums, the political leadership should take the question to parliament and the provincial assemblies, and build consensus there.
Published in Dawn, November 19th, 2026
The post Hardening lines appeared first on Dawn – Home.
