November 21, 2026
Breaking
Pakistan

Chinaman or doosra

admin5 min read

IT is well-nigh impossible to be so dependent on and enamoured of our dear friend China and not try to emulate it. Two huge economies share long land borders with us; both got their start around the same time as us, and both lapped us many times over in terms of economic development by any objective, empirical measures. Put yourselves in the decision-makers’ boots, and you too would, at least from time to time, wonder how to take their model and make it your own.

One among these giants practices the same multiparty system as we do — though both are far from perfecting it — but it happens to be the designated, permanent ‘arch-foe,’ and we would rather drown than accept a lifeline, real or metaphorical, from it.

The other is our ‘all-weather friend,’ and though its political and governance model is completely different, the powers that be would be tempted to emulate it for two reasons. One, centralised command makes it much easier to make tough decisions; two, it would give them more power. ‘We-know-best’ has become a mantra for overriding opposing arguments in determining the national interest and priorities.

Let us digress a little and see how much China we knowingly or unknowingly have in our lives, which could make the desire to copy them seem natural. As tea drinkers, though not totallers, we face one question countless times daily: “chini?” Whether our response is a technical one-half spoon or no sugar, we hardly ever stop to consider why refined sugar is called chini. Whether served in inexpensive pottery or fine porcelain, all non-metal drinkware is called chinaware.

China’s embrace of globalisation, especially through exports, helped millions around the world afford everyday goods and appliances of varying quality at competitive prices. Without belabouring the point, from EVs to restaurants to Chinatowns to alleged spy femme fatales, China is everywhere.

The Chinese have internalised their 5,000 years of history.

Borrowing from China’s experience is more complex than it appears; just as its products are famous for their copy-1, 2, 3 varieties, there are many Chinas as well. Recently, a social media clip shows an Afghan answering a Westerner’s question about how he views the world, saying, “This world is China, the real world is the afterlife.” Illusory, fake, a copy — take your pick of what he meant by ‘China.’

With the world’s greatest civilisations as neighbours, it’s hard to explain why we didn’t replicate their worldly successes. One obvious reason is that, though we are heirs to the great Indus civilisation, we chose to swap it for a faith-oriented identity, severing all ties to our Indus roots. An aversion to our true antecedents also explains why we fail to industrialise and become industrious; we try to mess up anything with ‘Indus’ in it.

It seems we may now be tempted to emulate the Chinese political system that produced one of the greatest military-industrial powers. The outlines of a new political order are already discernible, leaving less room for dissent. Chairman Mao’s famous ‘Let a hundred flowers bloom…’ did not have to specify whether they had to come from the same nursery.

In our haste to put things right, let’s not forget that the Chinese, among other things, are masters at biding their time because they have internalised their 5,000 years of history, whereas we have actively disowned ours. Even after unprecedented economic and military development, the Chinese waited for the Hong Kong lease to expire; Taiwan rankles them, but they take no rash action there either. They focused on putting their house in order before venturing into global affairs. Amid all the talk about a systemic reset, more provinces, constit­utional amendm­e­nts, and a referendum to assess the public will, we sho­­uld not forget that the Communist Party of China and its defence fo­­rces coalesced aro­und a people’s liberation movement. Our institutions are a colonial legacy.

I love the Chinese for a variety of reasons; not least among them is their resistance to cricket. Nations that are not cricket-crazy, ie South Korea, Japan, Vietnam, Thailand, Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Turkiye, Russia, and Germany, etc, have all overcome challenges and hardship.

It is strange, then, that an odd term in cricket refers to a chinaman. In a 1933 Test match between England and the West Indies, an English batter, Walter Robins, was stumped by a surprise delivery from Ellis Achong, a West Indian left-arm spinner of Chinese descent. As is their wont, the Englishman could not walk off the ground without a racial slur: “fancy being done by a bloody Chinaman.” We, the batters — read: battered — need to be vigilant, as, in addition to the chinaman, ambidextrous spinners also have a doosra in their repertoire.

The writer is a poet. His latest publication is a collection of satire essays titled Rindana.

shahzadsharjeel1@gmail.com

Published in Dawn, November 21st, 2026

The post Chinaman or doosra appeared first on Dawn – Home.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *