November 19, 2026
Breaking
Pakistan

‘Have the courage to listen to the debate you started’: Bilawal sticks to his guns after speaking his ‘truth’

admin9 min read

PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari on Wednesday maintained that his recent remarks on the country’s political situation were the “truth”, urging government representatives to have the “courage” to listen to his point of view.

Speaking in an interview on Hum News programme ‘Faisla Aap Ka’, Bilawal reiterated his stance from his Tuesday’s speech, cautioning against new provinces and calling for a “political reset” so public issues could be addressed.

Bilawal emphasised that he spoke in the context of the US-Iran war, which has impacted economies around the world due to rising energy costs.

“Elites do not have the idea of what kind of difficulties Pakistanis are facing,” he said, highlighting the need for politicians to set aside their partisan political perspectives and think about how to “fix the system”.

The PPP chairman asserted it was his right to provide his perspective on what shape a “reset” should take if someone was suggesting that a reset was needed, indirectly referring to Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi’s July remarks.

On the fact that his PPP was part of the ruling coalition, Bilawal contended that this was the exact reason to “listen” to him as he was a “major stakeholder”.

“These are not reasons to discount what I am saying […] I am telling you that this is the situation; these are my proposals to rectify it. You may disagree with my suggestions, but at least listen. You should have the courage to listen to the truth.”

The Bhutto scion added, “Because I am a stakeholder, I am saying: come to your senses.”

He further said, “Now let’s have the debate that you started. […] Have the courage to [continue] the debate that is now ongoing.”

Noting that the conversation had not been brought to the Parliament so far, Bilawal said, “You yourself decided to hold this debate in front of businessmen. It was decided on their own that this debate would be held through touts.”

The PPP chairman affirmed that Pakistan had not become so weak as a society that there would only be “one-sided debates”.

Replying to a question, he remarked that he “spoke too much yesterday, which was now hard to digest”.

Noting the ongoing “geopolitical atmosphere”, the former foreign minister wondered how many fronts the government wanted to fight on simultaneously, with India as an adversary, a near-war situation with Afghanistan and the fight against terrorism.

“The government has been deciding that we will fight the PTI; now the new decision is that they will also fight JUI, and it seems that after my truth, they have also decided they must fight me too,” Bilawal remarked.

“If you are going to fight everyone, and fight everyone internally as well, then who will lead Pakistan and its people out of this economic crisis?” he wondered.

The PPP chairman said the reactions from federal ministers to his remarks were “yet another proof that Pakistan’s politicians do not have the courage to hear the truth”.

“If you or they do not have enough courage or patience to listen to me, then what about the people of Pakistan who have no access to the prime minister, his ministers, or the National Assembly?”

‘Want PM Shehbaz to be strengthened’

Asked about his view if the government insisted on forming provinces, Bilawal said: “I would want to say to the incumbent government that the power of ‘kun fayakun’ belongs only to Allah Almighty and no one else.

“And if anyone is under the misconception that a decision was made, spoken, and thus done, then it will have an impact and consequences on our society, on our federation, on our politics, and on the lives of our people.”

On the PPP’s allyship with the PML-N, Bilawal said his party was with the government, keeping the national interest in view. He added, “Otherwise, there is political loss for me in bearing the burden of this government and this system.”

At the same time, he affirmed that his party still stood with the government and wanted Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif to be successful.

Clarifying any “misunderstanding” that PML-N might have, Bilawal said the aim of his address yesterday was that PM Shehbaz’s “hands are strengthened”.

Asked if he could leave the ruling coalition if he was not heard, the Bhutto scion said, “There is no extraordinary interest in sitting on the treasury benches or opposition benches.”

He added that if the government “did not have enough courage to tolerate the well-meaning input of their allies, then I wouldn’t lose any sleep if I was sitting on the opposition benches”.

‘Unaware of what is behind provinces debate’

Bilawal said he was unaware of “what was behind this debate because till today, despite being such a major stakeholder”, neither the prime minister nor a federal minister nor a political or any other stakeholder had discussed with him or the president that they wanted new provinces to be created.

“No attention” was being paid to the ongoing historic economic crisis, the ex-minister added.

Reiterating that he had not started the debate on governance, Bilawal quipped whether “only the PCB chairman had the right to tell how and why the system has collapsed”, referring to Naqvi, who also serves as the cricket board chief.

“If a reset has to happen, then has the PCB been given the responsibility that you have all powers to decide how the system will be reset, whether provinces should be divided? […] Should I go home quietly? This is not possible.”

Asked whether his remarks meant that PPP would take the path of resistance, Bilawal refrained from terming it that, adding that he provided his voters’ perspective and did not issue any protest call.

“I suggested to everyone that a political reset is needed, a democratic reset is needed, so that instead of politicians grabbing each other’s collars, fighting each other, we all join hands to pull the public out of this hardship,” he explained.

The PPP chairman termed the government’s reaction to criticism by Maulana Fazlur Rehman as “completely frivolous, irresponsible conduct”. “If he criticises, the reaction is to demolish the house, arrest his son and pressure his party workers,” he added.

Asked whether his warning regarding the division of Sindh was a threat, the Bhutto scion affirmed that his party was not one that engaged in violence.

He referred to Sindh’s history, particularly from the 1980s onwards, adding, “Was what I said outside of a historical context or precedent? This wasn’t organic; it was orchestrated to create division in Sindh’s politics.”

He declared, “And this risk is still present today, which is why I was warning that if Sindh is divided forcefully, I would not do such things but there will be a reaction.”

Bilawal warned that while he would not want it, the law and order situation would worsen so much that it would be difficult to put out the “fire”.

On 27th Amendment

On him questioning the 27th Amendment, Bilawal stressed that the amendment lacked the same “unanimous consensus” that was present for the 1973 Constitution and the 18th Amendment.

He stated that the 26th Amendment was passed with input from the opposition through the JUI-F chief, but it was the 27th Amendment that was followed by resignations of senior judges.

He emphasised that he was not calling for withdrawing the amendments, but that the opposition’s input be considered in such legislation.

In a separate interview on Geo News, Bilawal clarified he was “not disowning the 27th Amendment”.

He elaborated that there was a “difference” in the 18th, 26th and 27th Amendments regarding the consensus each of them had.

The PPP chairman declared he was “proud that we formed a constitutional court”, and that it had equal representation from all provinces.

Bilawal emphasised that he had presented suggestions on how confidence can be restored not just in the judiciary, but in other institutions as well, including the Parliament and the election commission, if there was to be a “political reset”.

“Do I believe the 27th Amendment could be more powerful with more input? Absolutely,” the PPP chief stated, stressing that he still believed judicial reforms were needed so that judges did not interfere in irrelevant matters.

“If you don’t want a reset, if you don’t want to improve the situation, then continue things as they are. But it can’t be that only one person is allowed and only one point of view is legitimate and any other is illegitimate.”

‘Reserved seats a low-hanging fruit if political reset pursued’

Speaking on Hum News about his remarks on reserved seats, Bilawal termed it a “low-hanging fruit if there was to be a political reset and if the opposition’s confidence was to be restored”.

“If we are to have a political reset, if we are to work towards a system that solves the economic issues of the people of Pakistan, one of the low-hanging fruits to improve the confidence of the opposition to convince them to start trusting Parliament in the political system is this suggestion — not this direction, not this insistence or red line.”

Asked about how such a process could begin as it would alter the coalition’s strength in the Parliament, Bilawal replied it could only happen if everyone agreed.

“If the government says no, we do not want to do so, then I cannot force anything,” said the PPP chairman about their ally PML-N.

Responding to a query about reserved seats on Geo News, Bilawal emphasised that his suggestion was “in the context of a political, democratic reset that could restore the trust of the opposition parties”.

He remarked that in the case of such a reset, considering giving back PTI its reserved seats “through the courts or legislation could be part of a confidence-building measure”.

On the PPP possibly giving up its reserved seats, Bilawal contended that this was “not the legal position as of now”, adding that they would not go to PTI even if his lawmakers resign.

“I think there’s an attempt of purpose to sensationalise what I said, to delegitimise and take out of context what I said, to serve some other purpose,” he further said.

The post ‘Have the courage to listen to the debate you started’: Bilawal sticks to his guns after speaking his ‘truth’ appeared first on Dawn – Home.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *