Defence Minister Khawaja Asif joined others from the ruling PML-N on Wednesday in responding to PPP Chairperson Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari following the latter’s hard-hitting speech over several issues, including new provinces, constitutional tweaks and treatment of the opposition.
“He who claims equity must come with clean hands,” Asif reminded Bilawal in a post on X, as the wrangling between coalition partners PML-N and PPP appeared to deepen.
The exchange has particularly heated up after Bilawal delivered a no-holds-barred speech the previous day that covered the question of new provinces. The Bhutto scion also expressed support for several opposition demands and questioned past decisions and actions taken by the ruling coalition.
Bilawal referred to Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi’s recommendation of holding a referendum to decide on the creation of new administrative units and said: “In our history, a referendum has always been carried out for an undemocratic act and never a democratic one.”
The PPP chairperson also remarked that the governance system had not collapsed, but was rather “made to collapse” — seemingly reacting to Naqvi’s statement in July that the current “system” of governance had “collapsed” and needed a “reset”.
Asif began his response to Bilawal by addressing this matter.
He said: “No system can reset without public support. If you are talking about a system collapse, then all of us, as people connected to this system, must also take stock of our responsibilities.
The defence minister also appeared to throw his weight behind the proposal for holding a referendum on new provinces as he said that there would surely be a debate on “system reset” in Parliament, but the public too could not be “deprived of its fundamental right”.
“The pinnacle of legitimacy would be reached if the public opinion is also taken into account along with that of Parliament.”
Seemingly reacting to Bilawal’s support for the release of incarcerated former prime minister and PTI founder Imran Khan and other demands by the opposition, Asif added: “Holding politicians accountable in this country is nothing new, and no politician exempt from accountability.”
He mentioned that the PPP had been in power in Sindh for 18 years.
“Sindh has turned into paradise. The world admires the condition of Karachi,” he said, seemingly taking a jibe at the PPP, which is often criticised over the lack of development in Sindh.
Asif then said Bilawal and his party had been a “partner of the PML-N in the business of government since 2022. You get the profit and the PML-N and Pakistan suffer loss”.
“He who claims equity must come with clean hands,” Asif continued. “This is a centuries-old maxim of equity. Are your hands clean? Do you have the right to lecture or threaten?”
The defence minister said, “We have just one objective: to change the lives of the people of Pakistan so that ordinary people can live with dignity. Make public participation in governance a reality … Do not confine the people’s rights to the pages of the Constitution.”
He said after achievements on diplomatic and military fronts, now the “fight is for devolving governance to grassroots, in which public opinion and Parliament’s role are entirely democratic and constitutional. Governance is not anyone’s monopoly; Allah has granted this right to 250 million people.”
‘Sins are not washed away in this manner’
Minister of State for Interior Tallal Chaudhry also reacted to Bilawal’s speech, saying that while the Bhutto scion presented himself as a “champion” of the Constitution and democracy, he was well versed only in theory on the subject and, in practice, his performance was “zero”.
He said Bilawal’s remarks the previous day were akin to picking and choosing certain provisions of the Constitution that suited him and disregarding others as unconstitutional.
Chaudhry said the PPP was currently in power in three provinces, as well as Gilgit-Baltistan. The president and Senate chairperson were also from the PPP, he further pointed out, commenting: “And then you give the impression as if you are the opposition leader, as if you are not associated with the government in any way.”
He also appeared to be criticising the PPP for being in favour of the creation of a south Punjab province and opposing the carving out of new administrative units in Sindh.
“So you call for breaking an administrative unit where governance is good and those where governance is bad should be left?”
The minister said Bilawal had also remarked that the 27th Amendment had been passed “with brute majority”.
“Were the votes cast the same way for the 1973 Constitution, or the 18th Amendment? Or do you believe that after voting like this, you can hold a press conference, act innocent and dissociate yourself, [as if] you did not realise [what was happening].
“Then you may also vote for the legislation for administrative units and later hold such a press conference saying it was due to force.
“Sins are not washed away in this manner. You cannot dissociate yourself in this manner,” he added.
“Everyone remembers that speech of yours in the National Assembly in which you said that a constitutional court was Quaid-i-Azam’s dream,” Chaudhry recalled.
“Then you referenced your mother’s speeches saying she wanted to create a constitutional court, and then you said — ‘This is our legacy. Carrying forward our legacy, today we have done the work that we had been wanting to do for the past 50 years’ — meaning the PPP wanted to do it. You took credit for the entire amendment, and today you’re saying that votes were cast forcibly.”
Chaudhry claimed Bilawal and his party opposed creation of new provinces in order to maintain control over resources. He referred to the PPP chairperson’s statement that if Sindh were to be divided, there could be bloodshed and called it “regrettable”.
“The question is: does casting a vote cause blood to flow, or does it stop bloodshed? You always say the decision should come through the ballot, not the bullet. So when did you start fearing the vote?” Chaudhry said.
“During 17 years of [PPP] rule, your governance has drained the blood of the people of Sindh. First check whether any blood is even left in them or not,” Chaudhry quipped.
According to the state minister, Bilawal merely wanted to accept “half the constitution” while claiming the rest as wrongly framed.
“In other words, are you calling the very Constitution you framed unconstitutional?” he asked.
“Democracy is not merely about delivering speeches, interpreting or explaining articles of the Constitution to show these are the rights of the people. Democracy also involves performance. Democracy also entails governance,” he added.
In response to Bilawal’s remarks on the 27th Amendment, Chaudhry said such amendments to the Constitution had been made over time to improve governance and held that the 27 amendments so far had also been made with that objective.
‘PPP crushed the move’
Separately, Health Minister Mustafa Kamal, whose party had also been demanding the creation of new administrative units in the country, questioned why the PPP was worried over the creation of new provinces if its performance in the government had been good.
Addressing a press conference in Islamabad, he painted a derelict picture of Sindh and asserted that power should be devolved to provinces.
He said the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan had tried to get this done through the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments, “but the PPP crushed” the move.
‘If govt lacks legitimacy, Zardari should resign’
Speaking to media in Islamabad, Jamaat-i-Islami (JI) chief Hafiz Naeem ur Rehman called on the PPP chairman to review his party’s history before opposing the creation of new provinces.
Rehman also challenged Bilawal to present Form-45s of the party’s seven National Assembly seats from Karachi.
The JI chief further stated that the PPP chairman should recall his party’s role in the ethnic unrest triggered by the 1972 language bill in Sindh before warning of bloodshed over the creation of new provinces.
He maintained that administrative provinces should be created through a constitutional process. The JI chief said that his party was in support of creation of fresh administrative units, provided it was done so constitutionally.
Rehman added that the PPP claimed the incumbent government was illegitimate; however, he pointed out that President Asif Ali Zardari secured his office with the support of the same government.
“If the government lacked legitimacy, Zardari should resign,” he said. Rehman also questioned Bilawal’s sympathy for PTI, asking why the PPP facilitated PTI government removal in the past. He also recalled that President Zardari had signed the order to impose governor’s rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.
The post 'He who claims equity must come with clean hands': Asif hits back at Bilawal appeared first on Dawn – Home.
